Hello dear
Welcome To Forest Hill General Store & Subs
At Forest Hill General Store & Subs, sandwiches transcend the ordinary, crafting a delightful experience rooted in community and quality. Nestled in Mifflinburg, PA, this charming store celebrates the art of sandwich-making with locally sourced ingredients and a menu that caters to every palate. From hearty subs to fresh, innovative options, every bite speaks of care and craftsmanship. The inviting atmosphere fosters connections, making it not just a place to eat, but a hub for locals and visitors alike. With a commitment to serving exceptional food, Forest Hill General Store & Subs stands as a culinary gem in the heart of Pennsylvania.
About
Forest Hill General Store & Subs
Welcome to Forest Hill General Store & Subs, where small-town charm meets hearty flavors! Located at 8750 Buffalo Rd, Mifflinburg, PA 17844, this hidden gem is not just a sandwich shop, but a beloved cornerstone of the community. With a phone number that’s always ready to take your order—(570) 966-0303—you’ll find a warm and inviting atmosphere as soon as you step inside.
At Forest Hill, sandwiches are the star of the show. The reviews speak volumes about their delectable offerings. Customer Osmar Toro raves about the friendly staff and the family feel, highlighting how both hot and cold subs are "always on point." It’s easy to see why families return time and again for those satisfying sandwiches that feel like home.
- Great Variety: Whether you're craving a classic cheesesteak or a tuna cosmo piled high with pickles, your taste buds are in for a treat. Local favorite Jeremy Caris swears by the small cheesesteak with extra meat, mayo, and hot wet peppers. If it’s the best in the area, you’ll definitely want to take his advice!
- Community Feel: Christine Kleman, another dedicated patron, shares that the staff remembers her regular order, showcasing the personalized service that keeps locals coming back. It feels good to be a part of such a welcoming environment where you’re known by name.
- Convenience: Beyond subs, this quaint store offers everything you might need, from essentials to freshly sliced cheese. Customer Cathy Winter enjoyed the affordable diesel fuel while appreciating the delightful service, proving that this spot serves more than just great food.
- Affordability: The pricing is competitive, as noted by Scott B., who found everything from groceries to fuel at reasonable rates, making it a smart stop for both locals and travelers alike.
Forest Hill General Store & Subs stands as a testament to the heart of Mifflinburg, where you can savor delightful sandwiches, friendly conversation, and the warm embrace of a community-driven establishment. Whether it's a quick lunch or a stop for fuel, this sub shop promises to leave a lasting impression. So why wait? Swing by for a taste of their signature sandwiches and experience the heartwarming hospitality that makes Forest Hill a local treasure.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Staff are always friendly and welcoming, Small town family feel. The subs whether I order hotcold are always on point. My family orders from here quite often. Continuingrepeat customers ”
“ Best cheesesteaks Ive found anywhere in the area! I recommend the small cheesesteak with extra meat, mayo, and hot wet peppers. ”
“ Love this place, what can I say!? Im a local and this is a very reputable family ran gas station and sub shop in our town! I eat their tuna cosmo with extra pickles at least twice a week. Best thing is, they already know my exact sub order ... ”
“ Nice little store has great subs, sweet young lady served us and was very nice, we enjoyed the little country store and diesel was cheaper than other stations in the area for our RV, we will definitely be visiting again soon ”
“ Small but packed with darned near anything you might need. Got some freshly sliced cheese while there filling up with fuel. The staff was very polite and friendly and pricing right in line with other markets. ”
“ The forest hill store will always have a special place in my heart. I walked there as a kid on summer days to buy a lot of cheap candy and later for subs. They make the best subs in the area. The subs are a bit more expensive these days but still better then subway. ”
“ Im a customer from back when Kermy owned and operated this store! I remember him telling you to go ahead through the little window to pump gas! I love that the owners through the years and now, Ron and Heather have kept the creeky old ... ”
“ The only downside to this store is that it is a little small. Otherwise it is great to stop at on your way up the mountain. Or to grab a bite to eat fresh made Hoagies are great! I recommend the regular! Very nice staff! ”